Black Friday has stopped being a Friday. Discounts now creep in from the first days of November, which is why some shoppers call the whole stretch Black November, and the day itself only arrives on 27th November. Between now and then, a row of gold stars will sit under almost everything on offer, from air fryers and new games to the online casino sites people are comparing in the same weeks.
Those stars are less reliable than they look. In a survey of 1,560 UK by certification body Amtivo, seven in ten had bought at least one thing in the past year that turned out worse than its reviews suggested, and 67% agreed it is becoming nearly impossible to know what is genuine online. These six checks take a few minutes and work the same way whether the thing in your basket is a gadget, a game or a casino account.
1. Look for Who Tested the Product
A star average tells you how people felt. It does not tell you whether anyone measured anything. Which? runs its own lab tests before it recommends a product, and its guide to when Black Friday deals start points shoppers to those independent reviews before they buy a so-called bargain.
Badges can fool us too. Amtivo showed its panel three trust marks it had invented alongside ten real ones, and around one in three people fell for at least one of the fakes.
2. Ask How the Reviewer Gets Paid
Plenty of review sites earn money when you click through and buy, and that is fine when they say so. Which? tells readers of its Deals newsletter that a retailer link can earn it an affiliate commission, so the arrangement is clear before anyone clicks.
Casino reviews work the same way, and the best ones are just as open about it. They name the author, explain how each site was tested, from the welcome page to the cashier, and say plainly how the review site earns its money. Those details are what separate trustworthy online casino reviews from a sales page with stars on it.
3. See When the Reviews Were Written
Scores age. A product page can show a 4.7 average built up over several years, while the last few months of reviews tell a different story after a design change or a new supplier. Sorting by newest first takes seconds and shows whether recent buyers agree with the old score.
The same goes for games, where a patch can change how a title plays long after launch, and for casino sites. A glowing casino rating from a few years ago says little if the site has since changed its payment options or how it handles withdrawals, so look for a recent update date on the review.
4. Read the One-Star Reviews First
The worst reviews show you what goes wrong. For a gadget, look for the same fault cropping up again and again, such as a battery that gives up after a month. For a game, check whether the complaints are about the whole thing or one disputed update.
On a casino review page, the most useful comments are about payouts and support. A review that explains how quickly support answered and how the cashier worked in practice tells you far more than one that only describes the games lobby.
5. Cross-Check a Second Source
Gamers have done this for years, weighing a critic score against what Steam players are saying. When both point the same way, you can relax, and when they split, it is time to read more.
Buying clothes online calls for the same caution, and a recent guide to streetwear shopping tells buyers to confirm a seller’s identity and reputation and to compare the full cost, delivery included, before ordering a hoodie. Two casino reviews deserve the same treatment: if one gives a site top marks and the other flags slow payouts, trust the one that explains how it reached its verdict.
6. Price-Check the Deal Itself
A glowing review of an overpriced product still leaves you with an overpriced product. Every year Which? compares Black Friday deals with prices in the six months before and after the sales weekend, and its 2025 investigation found that every deal it analysed was cheaper or the same price at another point in the year.
Which? senior researcher Ellie Simmonds says the one piece of advice to take away is “not to let yourself feel rushed”. Countdown clocks on product pages are built to do the opposite.
A star score is where the research starts, whether it sits under an air fryer, a game in the Steam sale or a casino site. Deals run right up to Cyber Monday on 30th November, so there is time to check all three properly.
